Corporal punishment policy could be reviewed, ENC Today (10.05.2011)
Onslow County Schools is one of few districts in the state that still allows corporal punishment. However, school officials are considering its review after a new legislation passed the N.C. General Assembly.
There has been a steady decline in its usage in school districts throughout the state, according to a release by Action for Children North Carolina. The decline is attributed to new legislation passed during the 2011 session of the N.C. General Assembly, which became effective at the beginning of the 2011-12 school year. That legislation requires school districts that allow corporal punishment to send out a form to all parents at the beginning of the school year allowing them to opt their children out of the punishment.
Carteret and Jones county school districts do not allow the practice. Onslow and Duplin County Schools are among the 21 districts listed as still allowing corporal punishment, according to the report.
However, the Duplin County School Board voted Sept. 20 to ban corporal punishment in all Duplin County Schools, said Dawn Craft, the spokeswoman for the district.
“No school plan for managing student behavior may authorize the use of corporal punishment,” she said. “The Duplin County Board of Education prohibits corporal punishment believing that other consequences are more appropriate and effective for teaching self control.”
School Board Chairwoman Pam Thomas said information about the new legislation in The Daily News made her think about the issue. She said she is considering putting it on the agenda at a school board workshop this month.
“I am surprised to find out it has been used,” she said. “It has not been a concern for us because it has not been abused … and we have had no complaints from parents. But we probably need to look at that policy.”
Corporal punishment is one of the last disciplinary measures considered by Onslow County School principals, said Assistant Superintendent Barry Collins, the spokesman for Onslow County Schools.
“Onslow County Schools’ stand on corporal punishment is it is a tool in the toolbox on discipline measures, but it is never the first tool used …That is the way it has been presented to principals,” he said.
Administrative Assistant to the Office of the Superintendent Jodie Ramsey said the last reported incident of corporal punishment administered in an Onslow County School was in March 2010, and it came at the request of the student’s parents. Prior to that, corporal punishment was administered twice in February 2008, again at the parent’s request, she said. Ramsey declined to reveal which schools administered the discipline.
The school district has sent opt-out notices to parents, Collins said. Each school keeps the notices, and the school district does not compile the number of parents who opt-out.
Onslow County School Board member Richard L. Ray noted that he comes from a time when it was acceptable and often used.
“I’m not against it,” he said. “I just think there are enough safeguards in place to make sure nothing untoward will happen. We have enough guidelines in place and we are cognizant of the fact that nothing should happen that is out of line.”
School Board member Brock Ridge thinks there are other ways to discipline students.
“I thought we had given that up, really,” he said. “I would not be in favor of it personally, even though when we first started we did use corporal punishment, but that was a different day and a different time … If it is being done then we need to revisit it.”
As a parent with three children in the Onslow County School District, Renae Pate, of Richlands, said she would like to see corporal punishment banned in the district.
“I feel like I should be the one to discipline my kids, not the schools,” she said.
Kasi Flores, who lives in the Summersill area, and has two children agreed.
“I don’t think it should be a school’s decision whether to do that or not. It should be a parent’s decision,” she said.
New requirements passed in 2009-10 require school districts to submit detailed data to the North Carolina Department of Public Instruction on the incidences of corporal punishment. DPI will release the data as part of its 2010-11 Consolidated Data Report in February.